South Africa Moves to WTO over EU’s Carbon Border Levy

South Africa Contemplates WTO Complaint Against EU's Carbon Border Levy — South African President Ramaphosa responds to a parliamentary debate on his state of the nation address in Cape Town

South Africa is deliberating lodging a formal complaint at the World Trade Organization (WTO) against the European Union’s proposed carbon border adjustment mechanism (CBAM).

This move comes in response to the EU’s plan to impose charges on the import of carbon-intensive products.

The products include among others – steel and cement, into Europe.

On Wednesday, Trade Minister Ebrahim Patel said they are still in the negotiation stage and would opt for to lodge complaint should the talks fail.

“We believe that first prize always is to reach an agreement through engagement and negotiation and our door remains open to find a settlement with the European Union on this matter,” Patel told Reuters.

“Failing everything else, we would be obliged to take the next step which would be to lodge a formal complaint (at the WTO), but we are still continuing discussions with a view to finding an amicable solution,” he added.

Also Read: Carbon credit market confidence ebbs as big names retreat

First Carbon Border Levy

The European Union initiated a trial phase for the world’s first carbon border levy in October.

Scheduled for full implementation from 2026, the levy will affect imports of steel, cement, aluminium, fertilizers, electricity, and hydrogen.

This initiative has drawn criticism from various quarters, including developing nations and industries like China’s steel sector.

Minister Patel called on EU to accommodate differential levels of development among nations, pointing out that the CBAM’s one-size-fits-all approach could disproportionately impact developing economies like South Africa.

On the other hand, a spokesperson from the European Commission defended the CBAM said the region’s move aligns with WTO regulations.

“EU domestic industry pays a carbon price. We need to make sure importers pay an equivalent price, based on the carbon content of their goods, to prevent carbon leakage and help reduce greenhouse gas emissions,” the spokesperson said.

“Carbon leakage” refers to the risk that, rather than reducing emissions, European industries would simply move abroad to avoid paying the EU’s domestic carbon price.

Importers Must Pay a Carbon Price

EU thinks importers must pay a carbon price equivalent to that borne by domestic industries, a measure intended to prevent carbon leakage and contribute to global emissions reduction efforts.

EU is South Africa’s largest trading partner and the latter says the move could result in strained trade relations between the two due to the levy.

An analysis by the South African Reserve Bank forecasted a possible 4% reduction in total exports to the EU by 2030, equivalent to a 0.02% decline in GDP, under the current CBAM framework.

May 23, 2024

176 2 minutes read

Lawrence Baraza

Lawrence Baraza is a dynamic journalist currently overseeing content at Metropol TV Digital. With a keen focus on business news and analytics, Lawrence guides the platform in delivering insightful, data-driven content that empowers its audience to make informed decisions. Lawrence’s commitment to quality and his ability to anticipate market trends make him a key figure in the digital media landscape. His work continues to shape the way business news is consumed, making a significant impact in the field.